Key takeaways
Tesla's current valuation appears slightly overvalued, primarily due to the high EV/EBITDA multiple (66.67) compared to the industry average (39.03). While the company's strong financial performance, technological leadership, and growth prospects support a premium valuation, the current price seems to be pricing in a scenario between the base case and optimistic case, leaving limited room for error. The potential for significant growth in FSD technology and energy storage is balanced against execution risks and increasing competition.
- Tesla's strong financial performance, with record Q3 results and high profitability, highlights its resilience in a challenging automotive market.
- The company's aggressive expansion plans, including new Gigafactories and product launches, carry significant execution risks, but also offer potential for long-term growth.
- Tesla's heavy investment in autonomous driving, battery technology, and manufacturing innovation could provide long-term competitive advantages, but also carries significant execution risks.
- The fragmented regulatory landscape for autonomous vehicles presents both challenges and opportunities, with successful approvals unlocking significant market potential.
- Tesla's expansion into energy storage and AI positions the company for long-term growth and diversification beyond its core automotive business.
Evaluation summary
-
Company Overview:
- Tesla, Inc. (TSLA) is a leading electric vehicle (EV) and clean energy company, designing, developing, manufacturing, selling, and leasing high-performance fully electric vehicles, solar energy generation and storage systems, and offering related services.
- Key products include the Model 3, Model Y, Model S, Model X, Cybertruck, and energy storage products like Powerwall and Megapack.
- The company operates in two main segments: automotive and energy generation/storage.
- Tesla sells vehicles directly to customers through an international network of company-owned stores and galleries.
- The company competes with established automakers as well as new entrants in the electric vehicle and clean energy markets.
- For comparative analysis, Tesla is benchmarked against the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLY) and compared to industry peers General Motors Co. (GM) and Uber Technologies, Inc. (UBER).
-
Financial Performance:
- Tesla's revenue has been growing steadily, reaching $25.18 billion in Q3 2024, up from $25.17 billion in Q4 2023.
- The company's net income has also been increasing, reaching $2.17 billion in Q3 2024, up from $7.93 billion in Q4 2023.
- Tesla's gross profit margin has been consistently above the industry average, reaching 19.84% in Q3 2024, compared to the industry average of -7640.00%.
- The company's net profit margin has also been significantly higher than the industry average, reaching 8.61% in Q3 2024, compared to the industry average of -19171.77%.
- Tesla's ROA, ROE, and ROIC have been consistently above the industry average, indicating strong asset utilization efficiency and profitability.
- Recent news highlights the company's strong financial performance, with record Q3 results despite industry headwinds.
- However, margins may face pressure from pricing competition and cost inflation.
-
Operational Efficiency:
- Tesla's working capital has been increasing, reaching $25.80 billion in Q3 2024, up from $20.87 billion in Q4 2023.
- This increase is primarily driven by growth in inventories and accounts receivable, potentially indicating inefficiencies in working capital management.
- The company's net operating cash flow has been strong, reaching $6.26 billion in Q3 2024, up from $4.37 billion in Q4 2023.
- Tesla's free cash flow margin has also been positive, reaching 0.11 in Q3 2024, indicating strong cash flow generation.
- The company's capital expenditures have been significant, reaching $3.51 billion in Q3 2024, reflecting its commitment to expanding its manufacturing capacity and product portfolio.
- Tesla has not paid dividends or repurchased shares, focusing on reinvesting its cash flow into growth initiatives.
- The company's liquidity ratios, including the current ratio and quick ratio, are above the industry average, indicating a strong ability to meet short-term obligations.
- Tesla's debt-to-equity ratio and leverage ratios have been decreasing, indicating a strong solvency position and a decreasing reliance on debt financing.
-
Growth Opportunities:
- Tesla is aggressively expanding its manufacturing capacity globally, with a new Gigafactory in Monterrey, Mexico, to increase production and meet growing demand.
- The company is investing heavily in R&D, particularly in autonomous driving, battery technology, and manufacturing improvements, with capital expenditures exceeding $11 billion in 2024.
- Tesla is targeting geographic expansion in key markets, including China, Europe, and North America, leveraging its strong brand recognition and growing demand for EVs.
- The company's strategic focus areas include the development and launch of more affordable vehicle models, the ramp-up of Cybertruck production, the continued expansion of the energy storage business, and significant advancements in FSD technology.
- Tesla is making progress on previously announced initiatives, including the rollout of a ride-hailing service and the development of its 4680 battery cells.
- The company's capital allocation strategy is focused on reinvesting cash flow into growth initiatives, including manufacturing expansion, R&D, and new product development.
-
Recent Developments and Market Sentiment:
- Recent news highlights Tesla's strong financial performance, with record Q3 results despite industry headwinds.
- The company's progress in FSD technology is crucial for future growth and competitive advantage, potentially transforming Tesla into a mobility services provider.
- Tesla's focus on cost reduction across all segments is essential for maintaining profitability and achieving its ambitious growth targets.
- The fragmented regulatory landscape for autonomous vehicles presents both challenges and opportunities, with successful approvals unlocking significant market potential.
- Tesla's expansion into energy storage and AI positions the company for long-term growth and diversification beyond its core automotive business.
- The lack of clarity regarding the relationship between Tesla and xAI raises concerns among investors about resource allocation and potential conflicts of interest.
- The significant outperformance of the Chinese market suggests a strong growth trajectory for Tesla in other regions as EV adoption increases.
- Overall market sentiment is positive, driven by the company's strong financial performance, technological advancements, and growth potential.
- However, concerns remain regarding the company's high valuation, execution risks, and regulatory challenges.
-
Risks and Threats:
- Tesla faces significant execution risks associated with its aggressive expansion plans, including the construction of new Gigafactories and the development of new products.
- The company's reliance on suppliers, including single-source suppliers, and potential supply chain disruptions pose a risk to its operations.
- Potential product quality issues, defects, or safety concerns could damage the company's reputation and financial performance.
- Ongoing legal proceedings and regulatory investigations pose legal and reputational risks that require close monitoring.
- The company's margins may face pressure from pricing competition and cost inflation.
- The fragmented regulatory landscape for autonomous vehicles presents challenges, with potential delays or restrictions impacting the rollout of FSD technology.
- The company's heavy investment in AI and robotics carries significant execution risks, with potential for delays, cost overruns, or technological challenges.
-
Valuation Analysis:
- Tesla's EV/EBITDA and EV/Sales ratios are significantly higher than the industry average, indicating a premium valuation compared to its peers.
- This premium valuation reflects investor expectations for continued growth, technological leadership, and market dominance.
- Potential catalysts for future valuation growth include the successful rollout of FSD technology, the launch of more affordable vehicle models, and the continued expansion of the energy storage business.
- However, the company's high valuation makes it susceptible to market volatility and investor sentiment shifts.
-
Price Performance:
- Tesla's stock price has been volatile, with periods of outperformance and underperformance relative to its peers and benchmarks.
- The company's stock price has outperformed the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLY) over the past six months, but has underperformed over longer timeframes.
- Tesla's stock price has consistently underperformed both General Motors Co. (GM) and Uber Technologies, Inc. (UBER) over the past three years, with the exception of the past six months.
- The company's high volatility and susceptibility to large drawdowns suggest a higher risk profile compared to its peers.
- However, recent outperformance and decreasing volatility may indicate a potential shift in investor sentiment and a more stable future performance.
-
Future Outlook:
- Tesla's management projects vehicle sales growth of 20% to 30% for 2025, barring unforeseen events.
- The company anticipates significant improvements in Full Self-Driving (FSD) capabilities, projecting that FSD will achieve safer-than-human driving performance by Q2 2025.
- Tesla plans to launch a ride-hailing service in California and Texas in 2025, subject to regulatory approvals.
- The company expects its internally produced 4680 battery cells to become the most cost-competitive in North America.
- Analyst estimates for Tesla's stock price vary widely, with some analysts projecting significant upside potential and others expressing concerns about the company's high valuation and execution risks.
- Recent news and developments suggest that Tesla's future performance will be influenced by factors such as the success of its FSD technology, the launch of more affordable vehicle models, the continued expansion of the energy storage business, and the company's ability to navigate regulatory challenges and macroeconomic uncertainties.
-
Summary:
- Tesla is a leading electric vehicle and clean energy company with a strong financial performance, high profitability, and a solid balance sheet.
- The company is aggressively expanding its manufacturing capacity and product portfolio to drive growth, but must navigate supply chain constraints, regulatory changes, and macroeconomic uncertainties.
- Tesla's heavy investment in autonomous driving, battery technology, and manufacturing innovation could provide long-term competitive advantages, but also carries significant execution risks.
- The company's financial performance has been strong, but margins may face pressure from pricing competition and cost inflation.
- Ongoing legal proceedings and regulatory investigations pose legal and reputational risks that require close monitoring.
- Tesla's stock price has been volatile, with periods of outperformance and underperformance relative to its peers and benchmarks.
- The company's high volatility and susceptibility to large drawdowns suggest a higher risk profile compared to its peers.
- However, recent outperformance and decreasing volatility may indicate a potential shift in investor sentiment and a more stable future performance.
- Tesla's future performance will be influenced by factors such as the success of its FSD technology, the launch of more affordable vehicle models, the continued expansion of the energy storage business, and the company's ability to navigate regulatory challenges and macroeconomic uncertainties.
Price history
Fundamentals
Insights
- Tesla's financial performance is strong, with high profitability, strong cash flow, and a solid balance sheet.
- The company is aggressively expanding its manufacturing capacity and product portfolio to drive growth, but must navigate supply chain constraints, regulatory changes, and macroeconomic uncertainties.
- Tesla's heavy investment in autonomous driving, battery technology, and manufacturing innovation could provide long-term competitive advantages, but also carries significant execution risks.
- The company's financial performance has been strong, but margins may face pressure from pricing competition and cost inflation.
- Ongoing legal proceedings and regulatory investigations pose legal and reputational risks that require close monitoring.
Analysis
- Revenue
- Tesla's revenue growth is moderate, but the company is still experiencing growth.
- Key revenue drivers include record vehicle deliveries, strong growth in the energy storage business, and increased revenue from Full Self-Driving (FSD) features.
- The Chinese market is outperforming the US and European markets, suggesting future growth potential in other regions.
- Profitability
- Tesla's profitability is strong and increasing, as evidenced by its increasing gross margin, operating margin, and net margin.
- The company's profitability is significantly above the industry average, highlighting its strong competitive position.
- Tesla's focus on cost reduction and efficiency is contributing to its strong profitability.
- Liquidity
- Tesla has a strong liquidity position, with a current ratio and quick ratio above the industry average.
- The company's liquidity position is improving, as evidenced by the increasing current ratio and quick ratio.
- Tesla's strong liquidity position provides it with flexibility to pursue its growth strategy and navigate potential economic challenges.
- Solvency
- Tesla has a strong solvency position, with a low debt-to-equity ratio and debt/EBITDA below the industry average.
- The company's solvency position is improving, as evidenced by the decreasing debt-to-equity ratio and debt/EBITDA.
- Tesla's strong solvency position provides it with the capacity to repay debt, invest in organic growth opportunities, and potentially return capital to shareholders.
- Operational Efficiency
- Tesla's asset utilization efficiency is improving, as evidenced by the increasing return on assets and return on equity.
- The company's efficiency is driven by its focus on cost reduction and operational improvements.
- Cash Flow Analysis
- Tesla's cash flow is strong, with a high net operating cash flow and free cash flow margin.
- The company is investing heavily in capital expenditures, reflecting its commitment to expanding its manufacturing capacity and product portfolio.
- The company's cash flow is expected to continue to grow in the coming quarters, driven by its strong profitability and expansion plans.
- Risk Factors
- The company's aggressive expansion plans, including the construction of new Gigafactories and the development of new products, carry significant execution risks.
- The company's reliance on suppliers, including single-source suppliers, and potential supply chain disruptions pose a risk to its operations.
- Potential product quality issues, defects, or safety concerns could damage the company's reputation and financial performance.
- Ongoing legal proceedings and regulatory investigations pose legal and reputational risks that require close monitoring.
- Future Outlook
- Tesla's future outlook is positive, with strong revenue growth, profitability, and cash flow expected to continue.
- The company's strategic initiatives, such as the development and launch of more affordable vehicle models, the ramp-up of Cybertruck production, and the continued expansion of the energy storage business, are expected to drive future growth.
- The company's strong financial position provides it with the flexibility to pursue its growth strategy and navigate potential economic challenges.
- Profitability
Financial statements
Public filings
- Tesla is a leading electric vehicle and clean energy company, but faces intensifying competition as the industry rapidly evolves
- The company is aggressively expanding its manufacturing capacity and product portfolio to drive growth, but must navigate supply chain constraints, regulatory changes, and macroeconomic uncertainties
- Tesla's heavy investment in autonomous driving, battery technology, and manufacturing innovation could provide long-term competitive advantages, but also carries significant execution risks
- The company's financial performance has been strong, but margins may face pressure from pricing competition and cost inflation
- Ongoing legal proceedings and regulatory investigations pose legal and reputational risks that require close monitoring
Core Business and Operations:
- Tesla designs, develops, manufactures, sells and leases high-performance fully electric vehicles, solar energy generation and storage systems, and offers related services
- Key products include the Model 3, Model Y, Model S, Model X, Cybertruck, and energy storage products like Powerwall and Megapack
- Operates in two main segments: automotive and energy generation/storage
- Sells vehicles directly to customers through an international network of company-owned stores and galleries
- Competes with established automakers as well as new entrants in the electric vehicle and clean energy markets
Industry and Market Trends:
- Electric vehicle adoption is increasing globally, driven by environmental regulations, consumer demand, and technological advancements
- Competition is intensifying as more automakers introduce new electric vehicle models
- Regulatory incentives and policies around electric vehicles, renewable energy, and emissions reductions can significantly impact the market
- Supply chain constraints, inflation, and macroeconomic conditions pose challenges for the industry
Recent Events:
- Announced the location of a new Gigafactory in Monterrey, Mexico to expand global manufacturing capacity
- Opened up the previously proprietary Supercharger connector as the North American Charging Standard (NACS), enabling other automakers to access the network
- Launched a new robotaxi product leveraging the company's autonomous driving technology
- Converted the company from a Delaware to Texas corporation
Risk Factors:
- Ability to successfully ramp production and deliveries of new products and features
- Reliance on suppliers, including single-source suppliers, and potential supply chain disruptions
- Potential product quality issues, defects, or safety concerns
- Exposure to fluctuations in foreign currency exchange rates
- Ability to attract and retain key personnel
- Ongoing legal proceedings and regulatory investigations
Legal Matters:
- Facing various lawsuits related to the 2018 CEO compensation plan, potential going-private transaction, alleged discrimination and harassment, and product/service claims
- Cooperating with ongoing investigations by government agencies on a range of operational and compliance matters
Management's Discussion and Analysis:
- Focused on profitable growth through capacity expansion, cost reduction, and new product introductions
- Investing heavily in R&D for autonomous driving, battery technology, and manufacturing improvements
- Generating positive operating cash flow to fund growth, with capital expenditures expected to exceed $10 billion in 2024
- Facing headwinds from macroeconomic conditions, supply chain challenges, and competitive pressures impacting pricing and margins
Earnings calls
Earnings Report 2024Q3 (2024-10-23)
Key takeaways
- Strong Financial Performance Despite Industry Headwinds: Tesla's record Q3 results demonstrate resilience in a challenging automotive market, highlighting its strong competitive position.
- Autonomous Driving as a Key Differentiator: Significant progress in FSD technology is crucial for Tesla's future growth and competitive advantage, potentially transforming the company into a mobility services provider.
- Cost Management and Efficiency are Critical: Tesla's focus on cost reduction across all segments is essential for maintaining profitability and achieving its ambitious growth targets.
- Regulatory Landscape Presents Both Challenges and Opportunities: Navigating the fragmented regulatory landscape for autonomous vehicles is a key challenge, but successful approvals could unlock significant market potential.
- Strategic Diversification Beyond Vehicles: Tesla's expansion into energy storage and AI positions the company for long-term growth and diversification beyond its core automotive business.
- Investor Uncertainty Regarding xAI's Impact: The lack of clarity regarding the relationship between Tesla and xAI raises concerns among investors about resource allocation and potential conflicts of interest.
- China Market as a Growth Engine: The significant outperformance of the Chinese market suggests a strong growth trajectory for Tesla in other regions as EV adoption increases.
Focus of management’s prepared remarks
- Record Q3 Performance and Profitability: Tesla achieved record deliveries and profitability in Q3 2024, exceeding expectations despite a challenging automotive market.
- Growth in Energy Storage: Strong demand for Megapack and Powerwall is driving significant growth in the energy storage business.
- Autonomous Driving Progress: Significant advancements in FSD technology are expected, with a target of surpassing human driving safety by Q2 2025. The October 10th event showcased autonomous vehicle capabilities.
- Affordable Vehicle Models: Tesla remains on track to deliver more affordable models starting in the first half of 2025, aiming for a sub-$30,000 price point with incentives.
- Cybertruck Production: Volume production of the Cybertruck is anticipated to begin in 2026, with a target of at least 2 million units per year.
- 4680 Battery Cell Cost Competitiveness: Tesla's internally produced 4680 battery cells are nearing cost competitiveness with other alternatives in North America.
- Expansion of Ride-Hailing: Tesla plans to launch a ride-hailing service in California and Texas in 2025, subject to regulatory approvals.
- Long-Term Vision: Tesla's long-term vision encompasses sustainable energy, transportation, robotics, and AI, positioning the company for future growth and market leadership.
Focus of the analyst Q&A
- Affordable Model Timeline and Alignment with AI Roadmap: Analysts inquired about the timeline for the more affordable model and its integration with Tesla's AI product roadmap. Concerns were raised about the availability of a $25,000 non-robotaxi model.
- Service Center Wait Times: Analysts sought an update on Tesla's efforts to reduce long wait times at service centers.
- Tesla Semi Update: Analysts requested an update on the Tesla Semi's production timeline, growth prospects, and the integration of FSD.
- Integration of X and Grok into Tesla Vehicles: Analysts asked about the timeline for integrating X and Grok into Tesla vehicles.
- Regulatory Approvals for Unsupervised FSD: Analysts questioned the status of regulatory approvals for unsupervised FSD in California and Texas, clarifying whether approval extends to all existing Model 3 and Y vehicles.
- Tesla's 2025 Plans: Analysts sought a detailed overview of Tesla's plans for 2025.
- Tesla Roadster Update: Analysts requested an update on the Tesla Roadster's development and launch timeline.
- Robotaxi Rollout Strategy: Analysts inquired about the planned rollout strategy for robotaxis, including the use of Tesla's own fleet versus customer-owned vehicles and the compatibility with Hardware 3.
- Relationship Between Tesla and xAI: Analysts sought clarification on the relationship between Tesla and xAI, addressing concerns about potential competition for talent, technology, and Elon Musk's time. The question highlighted investor uncertainty regarding the benefits of xAI to Tesla.
Summary
- Financial Performance
Tesla reported record Q3 2024 deliveries despite year-over-year industry declines in order volumes. The company achieved record Q3 results and generated record operating cash flows of $6.3 billion. Automotive revenues grew both quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year, although average selling prices (ASPs) decreased due to financing incentives. Energy storage business showed strong growth in demand for Megapacks and Powerwalls. Specific financial figures regarding profitability and margins are provided in the call but not explicitly stated as exceeding or falling short of analyst expectations.
- Revenue Drivers
Key revenue drivers included record vehicle deliveries, strong growth in the energy storage business, and increased revenue from Full Self-Driving (FSD) features ($326 million in Q3), including the release of FSD for Cybertruck and Actually Smart Summon. Elevated levels of regular 2-week credit sales also contributed significantly ($2 billion YTD). The Chinese market outperformed the US and European markets by a factor of three, suggesting future growth potential in other regions.
- Profit Margins and Cost Management
Automotive margins improved quarter-over-quarter due to increased production and delivery volume, favorable pricing, and localized deliveries. However, sustaining these margins in Q4 is expected to be challenging. Energy margins reached a record of over 30% in Q3, although fluctuations are anticipated. Tesla emphasized cost reduction efforts, aiming to lower the cost per vehicle and per megawatt-hour without compromising customer experience. The company achieved its lowest cost per kilowatt-hour in Q3.
- Guidance and Outlook
Management projected vehicle sales growth of 20% to 30% for 2025, barring unforeseen events. Cybertruck volume production is anticipated to begin in 2026, aiming for at least 2 million units annually, potentially reaching 4 million. Tesla expects its internally produced 4680 battery cells to become the most cost-competitive in North America. The company anticipates significant improvements in Full Self-Driving (FSD) capabilities, projecting that FSD will achieve safer-than-human driving performance by Q2 2025. Expansion of ride-hailing services in California and Texas is planned for 2025, subject to regulatory approvals. Capital expenditures (CapEx) for 2024 are expected to exceed $11 billion, largely due to investments in AI compute.
- Strategic Initiatives
Key strategic initiatives include the development and launch of more affordable vehicle models (sub-$30,000 with incentives), the ramp-up of Cybertruck production, the continued expansion of the energy storage business, significant advancements in FSD technology, the rollout of a ride-hailing service, and substantial investments in AI compute infrastructure. Tesla is also focusing on improving service center efficiency and expanding its network. The company highlighted its vertically integrated approach, controlling vehicle production, service, and software development.
- Management Commentary
Management expressed confidence in Tesla's performance and future prospects, emphasizing its profitability in a challenging automotive market and its technological leadership in electric vehicles, autonomous driving, and energy storage. The overall tone was optimistic, projecting significant growth and market dominance. Elon Musk repeatedly highlighted the transformative potential of autonomous driving and the long-term value of Optimus (humanoid robot).
- Industry and Market Conditions
Tesla acknowledged a challenging automotive environment with declining order volumes across the industry. Management noted that most EV companies are unprofitable, highlighting Tesla's unique position. The company believes that declining interest rates could positively impact automotive demand. The impact of macroeconomic factors, such as interest rates and geopolitical events, was acknowledged as a potential risk.
News evaluation
Comparative analysis
Benchmarks (as of 2024-10-11)
- Performance Comparison:
- TSLA has underperformed XLY over most of the historical periods analyzed, particularly over the past year and two years. This suggests that TSLA has been more susceptible to market downturns than the broader Consumer Discretionary sector. However, TSLA has outperformed XLY over the past six months, indicating a potential shift in investor sentiment.
- Risk and Return Analysis:
- TSLA has provided lower annualized returns than XLY over the past three years. This suggests that TSLA has not been as profitable as the broader Consumer Discretionary sector.
- TSLA has been significantly more volatile than XLY, as evidenced by its higher annualized volatility. This indicates that TSLA's price movements have been more erratic and unpredictable than XLY's.
- TSLA has experienced significantly larger maximum drawdowns than XLY. This indicates that TSLA is significantly more susceptible to large price declines than XLY.
- Risk-Adjusted Performance:
- XLY has consistently offered a better risk-adjusted return than TSLA, as indicated by its higher Sharpe ratio. This suggests that XLY has been a more efficient investment than TSLA, providing higher returns for a given level of risk.
- TSLA's higher beta indicates that it is a riskier investment than XLY. This suggests that TSLA's price is likely to fluctuate more than XLY's during periods of market volatility.
- Overall Assessment:
- TSLA has underperformed XLY in terms of both absolute and risk-adjusted returns over the past three years. This suggests that TSLA has been a less profitable and riskier investment than the broader Consumer Discretionary sector. However, TSLA's recent outperformance over the past six months and its decreasing volatility in recent quarters may indicate a potential shift in investor sentiment and a more stable future performance. Investors should carefully consider TSLA's high volatility and susceptibility to large drawdowns before making any investment decisions.
Peers Price History(as of 2024-10-11)
- Performance Comparison:
- TSLA has consistently underperformed both GM and UBER over the past three years, with the exception of the past six months. This underperformance is particularly pronounced in the longer timeframes, such as the one-year, two-year, and three-year periods.
- TSLA's performance has been inconsistent relative to the peer companies, with periods of outperformance and underperformance.
- Risk and Return Analysis:
- TSLA has provided lower annualized returns than both GM and UBER over the past three years. This suggests that TSLA's growth potential may be lower than its peers.
- TSLA has been significantly more volatile than both GM and UBER, as evidenced by its higher annualized volatility. This indicates that TSLA's stock price is more susceptible to fluctuations and market swings.
- TSLA has experienced larger maximum drawdowns than both GM and UBER. This suggests that TSLA's stock price is more vulnerable to significant declines and carries a higher risk profile.
- Risk-Adjusted Performance:
- TSLA's Sharpe Ratio has been consistently lower than GM's and UBER's, indicating that TSLA has not offered a better risk-adjusted return. This suggests that TSLA's returns have not adequately compensated for its higher risk.
- TSLA's beta value has been consistently higher than GM's and UBER's, indicating that it is more sensitive to market movements. This suggests that TSLA's stock price is more likely to fluctuate in line with broader market trends, potentially amplifying both gains and losses.
- Overall Assessment:
- TSLA has consistently underperformed both GM and UBER over the past three years, with the exception of the past six months. This underperformance is particularly pronounced in the longer timeframes, such as the one-year, two-year, and three-year periods.
- TSLA's higher volatility and larger drawdowns suggest that it carries a higher risk profile than its peers.
- TSLA's lower Sharpe Ratio indicates that its returns have not adequately compensated for its higher risk.
- TSLA's higher beta suggests that it is more sensitive to market movements, potentially amplifying both gains and losses.
- Overall, TSLA's performance, risk, and valuation metrics suggest that it may be a riskier investment than its peers. Investors should carefully consider these factors before making any investment decisions.
Peers Fundamentals(as of 2024-09-30)
-
Market Position and Size:
- TSLA's market capitalization is significantly larger than its peers, General Motors (GM) and Uber Technologies (UBER), indicating that the market values TSLA significantly higher than its peers, likely due to its focus on electric vehicles and its perceived growth potential.
- While TSLA's market cap is significantly larger than its peers, its revenue is less than GM's and greater than UBER's, suggesting that TSLA's valuation is not solely driven by its current revenue performance, but rather by investor expectations of future growth and profitability.
- TSLA's EBITDA is also significantly lower than GM's but greater than UBER's, further supporting the notion that TSLA's valuation is driven by growth expectations rather than current profitability.
- Overall, TSLA's market position is characterized by a significantly higher market capitalization compared to its peers, despite having a smaller revenue base than GM and a larger revenue base than UBER. This suggests that the market has high expectations for TSLA's future growth and profitability, which are not yet reflected in its current financial performance.
-
Profitability and Efficiency:
- TSLA's profitability metrics are mixed compared to its peers and industry averages. While TSLA has a higher Gross Profit Margin than GM, it is lower than UBER's and significantly higher than the industry average.
- TSLA's EBITDA Margin is also higher than both GM and UBER, and significantly higher than the industry average.
- However, TSLA's Net Profit Margin is lower than both GM and UBER, but significantly higher than the industry average.
- Considering TSLA's size and revenue, its profitability metrics are relatively strong. Despite having a smaller revenue base than GM, TSLA's EBITDA Margin is higher, indicating its ability to generate operating profits efficiently. However, its Net Profit Margin is lower than its peers, suggesting that TSLA may face challenges in converting operating profits into net income.
- Overall, TSLA's profitability metrics are a mixed bag. While it outperforms its peers and the industry in terms of Gross Profit Margin and EBITDA Margin, its Net Profit Margin is lower than its peers. This suggests that TSLA's profitability is strong in terms of operating efficiency, but may be impacted by other factors that affect its net income.
-
Financial Health and Stability:
- TSLA's liquidity and solvency metrics are mixed compared to its peers and industry averages. TSLA's Current Ratio and Quick Ratio are higher than both GM and UBER, but lower than the industry average.
- TSLA's Total Debt to Total Equity Ratio and Debt / EBITDA are significantly lower than both GM and UBER, and lower than the industry average, suggesting that TSLA has a relatively low level of debt compared to its peers and the industry, indicating a strong financial position.
- TSLA's liquidity and debt position are strong relative to its market cap and peer group. Its low debt levels and strong ability to meet short-term obligations suggest a healthy financial position. However, its liquidity metrics are lower than the industry average, which may indicate potential challenges in meeting short-term obligations in the future.
- Overall, TSLA's liquidity and solvency metrics are a mixed bag. While its low debt levels and strong ability to meet short-term obligations suggest a healthy financial position, its liquidity metrics are lower than the industry average, which may indicate potential challenges in meeting short-term obligations in the future.
-
Valuation and Market Perception:
- TSLA's valuation metrics are significantly higher than its peers and industry averages, reflecting the market's high expectations for its future growth and profitability. This high valuation is not solely driven by its current financial performance, but rather by investor optimism about its long-term prospects.
- Overall, TSLA's valuation metrics are significantly higher than its peers and industry averages, reflecting the market's high expectations for its future growth and profitability. This high valuation is not solely driven by its current financial performance, but rather by investor optimism about its long-term prospects.
-
Cash Flow and Capital Management:
- TSLA's cash flow metrics are mixed compared to its peers, considering their market caps. While its Net Operating Cash Flow is lower than GM's, its Free Cash Flow is higher than both GM and UBER, suggesting that TSLA is effectively managing its capital expenditures and generating cash for future growth and shareholder returns.
- Overall, TSLA's cash flow metrics are mixed compared to its peers, considering their market caps. While its Net Operating Cash Flow is lower than GM's, its Free Cash Flow is higher than both GM and UBER, suggesting that TSLA is effectively managing its capital expenditures and generating cash for future growth and shareholder returns.
-
Growth and Future Prospects:
- TSLA's growth metrics show a mixed picture compared to the peer group average. TSLA consistently shows higher growth in sales, EBITDA, and book value per share, but lower growth in net income, basic earnings per share, free cash flow, and free cash flow margin.
- TSLA's growth rates exhibit significant year-to-year fluctuations, particularly in net income, basic earnings per share, free cash flow, and free cash flow margin, suggesting that TSLA's growth is not always consistent and may be subject to volatility.
- Comparing TSLA's 3-year and 5-year CAGR figures reveals that its 5-year CAGR is higher for sales, EBITDA, and book value per share, while its 3-year CAGR is higher for free cash flow. This suggests that TSLA's growth has been accelerating in recent years for sales, EBITDA, and book value per share, but decelerating for free cash flow.
- TSLA's growth trends suggest that it is outperforming its peers in terms of sales, EBITDA, and book value per share, but underperforming in terms of net income, basic earnings per share, free cash flow, and free cash flow margin. This suggests that TSLA's growth is not always consistent and may be subject to volatility.
- Overall, TSLA's growth profile is characterized by strong growth in sales, EBITDA, and book value per share, but weaker growth in profitability and cash flow metrics. While its growth has been accelerating in recent years for sales, EBITDA, and book value per share, it has been decelerating for free cash flow. This suggests that TSLA's growth may not be sustainable in the long term, and investors should monitor its profitability and cash flow generation closely.
-
Potential for Investment:
- TSLA's investment attractiveness is a complex issue, characterized by its high growth potential, strong profitability, and conservative debt structure, but also by its lower Net Profit Margin and fluctuating growth rates. Its high valuation reflects the market's optimism about its future prospects, but also raises concerns about its sustainability.
- Investors seeking exposure to the electric vehicle market and willing to accept a high valuation and potential volatility may find TSLA attractive. However, investors seeking more stable and predictable growth may prefer other companies in the industry.
- Overall, TSLA's investment attractiveness is a complex issue, characterized by its high growth potential, strong profitability, and conservative debt structure, but also by its lower Net Profit Margin and fluctuating growth rates. Its high valuation reflects the market's optimism about its future prospects, but also raises concerns about its sustainability.
-
Key Risks and Considerations:
- TSLA's lower Net Profit Margin and fluctuating growth rates suggest that its profitability may be impacted by factors beyond its operating performance, such as interest expenses or taxes, and its growth may not be sustainable in the long term.
- TSLA's high valuation, driven by investor optimism about its future prospects, raises concerns about its sustainability and potential for a significant decline in value if its growth expectations are not met.
- TSLA's reliance on regulatory credits for a portion of its revenue may be subject to changes in government policies, which could impact its profitability.
- TSLA's rapid expansion and aggressive investment in new technologies may lead to increased costs and potential challenges in managing its operations effectively.
- TSLA's dependence on a single CEO, Elon Musk, may create risks related to his leadership style and potential for succession issues.
-
Overall Assessment:
- TSLA is a financially strong company with a dominant market share in the electric vehicle market. Its strong profitability, high return on capital, and conservative debt structure suggest that TSLA is well-positioned for future growth. However, its lower Net Profit Margin and fluctuating growth rates suggest that TSLA may face challenges in maintaining its competitive advantage in the long term.
- TSLA's high valuation reflects the market's optimism about its future prospects, but also raises concerns about its sustainability and potential for a significant decline in value if its growth expectations are not met.
- Overall, TSLA is a promising company with significant growth potential, but investors should be aware of the risks associated with its high valuation, fluctuating growth rates, and dependence on a single CEO.